The New York Giants' decision to re-sign Evan Neal, a 2022 seventh-overall pick, is a surprising move that sparks curiosity. While the team's right guard problem was a concern, the idea of Neal as a solution is intriguing. Let's delve into the tape and explore the possibilities.
Power and Quickness
Neal's strength lies in his power as a run blocker, especially when blocking downhill. He's a force to be reckoned with, capable of moving defenders and distorting the line of scrimmage. Despite his height, he works hard to maintain leverage against defensive tackles. Additionally, Neal's quickness is notable, especially when pulling and working to the second level.
Hand Placement and Lateral Agility
However, there are areas for improvement. Neal tends to hug defenders when blocking laterally in zone schemes, letting his hands drift wide and engaging with shoulder pads instead of chest plates. This affects his ability to control and sustain blocks. Nevertheless, his lateral agility is good, mirroring interior rushers and keeping them in front of him.
Redirection and Overall Performance
Neal's performance at offensive tackle showcased a tendency to over-set to the outside against speed, which also appeared at guard. This suggests that his redirection skills need work. Despite these challenges, the Giants' decision to re-sign Neal hints at a belief in his potential.
Fresh Eyes and Upside
Looking back at the 2025 preseason tape, I saw a player with potential. While he wasn't great, the limited experience and time under his belt should be considered. The comparison between Neal and Greg Van Roten was intriguing, suggesting upside. However, the Giants' decision to bench Neal raised questions about their trust in him.
Conclusion and Future Considerations
In my opinion, Neal could be a viable solution at right guard, but it's not a guaranteed answer. The Giants should consider giving him a chance to win the job while having a reliable backup plan. Signing a veteran like Van Roten and drafting a guard prospect for future development could be a strategic approach. This way, they can address the right guard position and potentially find a long-term solution.
